EMAIL VS SEARCH --
WHICH WORKS BEST TO GET NEW CUSTOMERS?

 

SUMMARY: DMNews raises some interesting questions about whether Email or Search is best for getting new customers. Read more about it in this article...

DMNews is a good source of information about Direct Marketing.  They regularly run a couple of special issues, one on Search Marketing, the other covering Email Marketing.

If you haven't seen these issues, one conclusion may surprise you. I understand them to say:

If you're trying to reach new customers online, use SEARCH MARKETING.  Don't try to use Email to get new customers. It won't work.

Although list brokers might argue, you can't buy a targeted list of email addresses the same way you can buy a list of street addresses for Direct Mail.  Or I should say, you can BUY it but it WON'T WORK -- not like Direct Mail.

Email is NOT street mail... 

  • There are too many restrictions and too many constraints on what you can send to whom.
  • And people keep switching email addresses, or using dummy addresses to prevent junk mail
  • And you don't have enough room in the recommended-35-character-limit subject line to get a flea's attention, much less attract the interest of someone who doesn't know or care about you
  • And there's too little information about the recipients for you to effectively reach a group you're trying to target.

With street mail, it's easy to target by demographics and even psychographics.  For example -- You can accurately mail to all the people with incomes over a certain level and who have 2.5 kids and dogs with one brown eye who've purchased from department stores before.  (The people have bought at stores, not the dogs...)

Online?  Forget about it.

Gary Bencivenga underscores the point in a recent BencivengaBullets issue.  He goes even further.  He says the best way to sell online could well be to have a different site for every product with a different landing page for every search term.  Throwing yourself in front of a prospect when they're looking is your only hope of catching a new customer.

Is Email Good for Anything Anymore?

Email does still have many strengths.  As it's always been, it's good for maintaining a relationship with a past customer. 

And... You can use email to sell additional items -- if the relationship is solid

But even then, it's all too easy for your customer to jump from your email to a search engine.  There they look up all the competitive products in the area where your email just raised their awareness. 

That means: if you're going to use email to sell those additional products, use every persuasive tool you have in that email. Especially your USP - what's unique about you that serves as a competitive advantage. Don't let 'em think they can get what you're selling anywhere else on the planet!

Otherwise - like a lot of things web marketers do - your email could turn out to just be advertising for your competition.

 

Home -> Article Archives -> EMail Vs Search

Author Credit

RA Murphy owns and runs internet marketing solutions firm, RA Murphy & Company. Online since 1996, Murphy has worked more than 35 years in computer technology. His firm serves clients by solving their traffic and conversion problems and finishing web projects left incomplete by others. Murphy specializes in fixing the mistakes that others make.

More information is available at the website, RAMurphy.com.

 

Reprint Policy

Want to Use this Article Elsewhere?

Terms and Conditions of Use: The content on this page (but not the design, logo or other website elements) may be freely copied and posted, printed or distributed elsewhere so long as the two conditions below are met:

1. The article must run in its complete, unedited state.

-and-

2. Credit must be given using the exact wording in the "Author Credit" box above.

If you have any questions about this policy, feel free to contact us.